Shivam Das Bulletin News is a community wire. Some contributors post age-restricted
(NSFW) content, labeled where it appears. You need to confirm you're
old enough to view that kind of content before entering the site.
This choice is only stored in your own
browser (localStorage) — nothing is sent to the server, and it never
unlocks any specific post; individual NSFW posts still show their own
label wherever they appear.
Every story gets a byline, a signal score, and a place on the wire.
+ Start writing
BusinessNSFWUNPUBLISHED
Dave Ramsey Slams IRS Tax Withholding as 'Brilliant Psychological Trick' on The Ramsey Show
Shivam Das
July 10, 2026
Dave Ramsey Slams IRS Tax Withholding as 'Brilliant Psychological Trick' on The Ramsey Show
On July 8, 2026, Dave Ramsey and his co-host George Kamel discussed income tax withholding on The Ramsey Show, labeling it a "brilliant psychological trick" that hides the true burden of government taxation from citizens. According to the IRS, over 150 million taxpayers received an average refund of
,827 in 2025, which can create an illusion of lower tax burden. This withholding system, introduced in 1943, allows employers to deduct taxes from employees' paychecks and remit them directly to the government.
Ramsey argues that if taxpayers saw the actual amount of money being withheld from their paychecks, they would be more likely to feel the pain of taxation and potentially take action. He suggests adjusting W-4 withholdings to minimize refunds, aiming for zero owed or refund. By doing so, individuals can keep their money throughout the year, invest it, or pay off debt, rather than loaning it interest-free to the government.
Key Facts and Background
The system of income tax withholding was introduced in 1943 as part of the Current Tax Payment Act to fund the war effort. Milton Friedman, then working at the Treasury Department, helped design the system but later regretted it, stating that it enabled bigger government by reducing the visibility and pain of taxes. Friedman noted in his memoirs that the focus was on war needs, without considering the long-term consequences of making government "too large, too intrusive."
The modern withholding system has its roots in the 1913 income tax, which allowed for limited "collection at the source." However, the broad modern withholding system began in 1943. Beardsley Ruml's "pay-as-you-go" plan played a significant role in selling the concept, with partial tax forgiveness during the transition period.
Ramsey's Views and Practical Advice
Dave Ramsey emphasizes the importance of adjusting W-4 withholdings to minimize refunds, aiming for zero owed or refund. He suggests using last year's refund divided by 12 to estimate adjustments. By doing so, individuals can keep their money throughout the year, invest it, or pay off debt, rather than loaning it interest-free to the government. For self-employed individuals, Ramsey recommends setting aside 25-30% quarterly.
Psychological Effects of Withholding
The withholding system creates an illusion of lower tax burden by making taxes "out of sight, out of mind." Refunds reinforce this by framing over-withholding as a "bonus" from the government, which is actually the taxpayer's own money, loaned interest-free to Uncle Sam. Critics argue that this system enabled post-WWII government growth by reducing public resistance to higher taxes or government spending.
Criticisms and Reactions
The post taps into libertarian-leaning frustrations with government size, fiscal opacity, and "nanny state" mechanisms. Withholding, combined with automatic deductions (FICA, etc.) and refunds, creates an illusion of lower burden. Critics argue that it enabled post-WWII government growth by reducing public resistance to higher taxes or government spending.
Implications and Future
The discussion on The Ramsey Show highlights the need for taxpayers to be aware of the withholding system and its effects. By adjusting W-4 withholdings and keeping their money throughout the year, individuals can take control of their finances and make informed decisions about their tax burden. As the tax landscape continues to evolve, it is essential for taxpayers to stay informed and advocate for transparency in government taxation.
The primary purpose of income tax withholding is to collect taxes from employees' paychecks and remit them directly to the government, ensuring steady revenue for the government. However, critics argue that it enables bigger government by reducing the visibility and pain of taxes.
How does the withholding system create an illusion of lower tax burden?
The withholding system creates an illusion of lower tax burden by making taxes "out of sight, out of mind." Refunds reinforce this by framing over-withholding as a "bonus" from the government, which is actually the taxpayer's own money, loaned interest-free to Uncle Sam.
What is the recommended approach to adjusting W-4 withholdings?
Dave Ramsey suggests adjusting W-4 withholdings to minimize refunds, aiming for zero owed or refund. He recommends using last year's refund divided by 12 to estimate adjustments.
How does the withholding system affect self-employed individuals?
For self-employed individuals, Ramsey recommends setting aside 25-30% quarterly to account for taxes. This helps them avoid underpayment penalties and ensures they have enough funds for taxes throughout the year.
What is the significance of Beardsley Ruml's "pay-as-you-go" plan in the context of income tax withholding?
Beardsley Ruml's "pay-as-you-go" plan played a significant role in selling the concept of income tax withholding. The plan involved partial tax forgiveness during the transition period, which helped to make the system more palatable to taxpayers.
Conclusion
The discussion on The Ramsey Show highlights the importance of understanding the income tax withholding system and its effects on taxpayers. By adjusting W-4 withholdings and keeping their money throughout the year, individuals can take control of their finances and make informed decisions about their tax burden. As the tax landscape continues to evolve, it is essential for taxpayers to stay informed and advocate for transparency in government taxation.
This dispatch is for subscribers
Subscribe to to keep reading.
0 views
Comments (0)
‹ Prev
Next ›
Page not found
That dispatch or profile doesn't exist, or may have been removed.
Know something about this story?
You can add information to this dispatch — the author gets to review it.
